Blog

THD vs Hemorrhoidectomy, Stapler and Laser: Which One Suits You?

Four ways to treat hemorrhoids surgically, compared on pain, recovery and recurrence, so you can discuss the right option with your surgeon.

When simple treatment stops working, patients hear several names: traditional surgery, stapler, laser and THD. Each one works differently, and each has its place. In this guide, Dr. Ibrahim Gamal, Consultant Colorectal and Laser Surgeon in Abu Dhabi, explains the difference in plain words.

The four options at a glance

THDTraditional hemorrhoidectomyStaplerLaser
What the surgeon doesTies the feeding arteries and lifts the tissue with stitchesCuts the hemorrhoids outRemoves a ring of tissue above the hemorrhoids and staples itShrinks the hemorrhoid from inside with laser energy
Tissue removedNoYesYes, a ring of rectal liningNo
WoundsNo external woundOpen or stitched wounds in a sensitive areaInternal staple lineTiny entry points
Pain after surgeryUsually mild to moderateUsually the highest of the fourUsually mild to moderateUsually mild
Typical useGrades 2 to 4, bleeding and prolapseLarge grade 3 and 4, external componentsProlapse, grades 3 and 4Grades 2 and 3

THD compared with traditional surgery

Traditional hemorrhoidectomy removes the hemorrhoids completely. It has the lowest chance of the problem returning, and it is still the right choice for some patients. Its main drawback is the wound, which sits in an area full of pain nerves.

THD, as performed by Dr. Ibrahim Gamal, removes nothing. Studies comparing the two show less pain and a faster return to work and social life after THD. The trade-off is that symptoms can return in some patients, more often in grade 4.

THD compared with the stapler

Both lift prolapsed hemorrhoids. The stapler removes a ring of tissue, while THD uses stitches only. Reviews of trials found slightly lower pain scores with THD and a somewhat lower recurrence with the stapler. The stapler also carries a small risk of rare but serious complications, which is one reason many surgeons now prefer THD.

THD compared with laser

Laser shrinks the hemorrhoid from inside and suits small to medium hemorrhoids. THD can add a lift for hemorrhoids that come out, which the laser alone cannot do for large prolapse. In some patients the surgeon combines techniques.

So which one is right?

The answer depends on the grade, the main symptom, earlier treatments and your general health. This is why Dr. Ibrahim Gamal offers more than one technique and chooses according to your examination, not the other way round.

Dr. Ibrahim Gamal offers THD, THD Anolift and laser treatment at Burjeel Hospital, Abu Dhabi. Book a consultation to discuss the option that fits your case.

This article is general information and does not replace a medical consultation. Your treatment depends on your examination.

Talk to Dr. Ibrahim Gamal

Book a consultation at Burjeel Hospital, Abu Dhabi, or ask your question privately on WhatsApp.

WhatsApp Book